EU-South American Trade Deal—What does France think?

A meeting of the European Parliament

The recently finalised EU-Mercosur trade deal, covering 800 million people across two continents, has sparked celebration among proponents of free trade and sustainability—but also fierce opposition, particularly from France. Paris’s resistance spotlights deep-seated tensions between national priorities and EU-wide economic policy. Why is France opposed?

Agricultural Concerns 

France, benefitting from a robust agricultural sector, views the agreement as a direct threat to its farmers. The deal facilitates exporting Mercosur agricultural products, including beef, soybeans, and ethanol, to Europe at reduced tariffs. French farmers worry that they cannot compete with the cheaper, large-scale production methods prevalent in South America, which often rely on less stringent labour and environmental standards.

Political Pressures 

Domestically, Macron faces significant pressure from influential agricultural unions and green political movements, who have voiced strong opposition to the agreement. Supporting the deal could alienate these critical voter bases, making it politically risky for Macron to endorse it without stronger environmental safeguards. Political considerations are especially relevant following the collapse of the French government, which failed a no-confidence vote this past Wednesday.

Who benefits?

While French farmers may see this deal as a threat, it offers substantial benefits to certain sectors and regions:

Automakers and machinery manufacturers in countries like Germany and Spain gain access to new South American markets. Brazil and Argentina, in particular, will see expanded agricultural exports to Europe, boosting their economies. For the EU, the deal diversifies trade relationships and reduces dependence on China for raw materials and commodities.

French resistance indicates a broader challenge in EU policymaking: balancing national interests with collective goals. France’s position complicates the ratification process, as the EU requires consensus among member states. Macron has called for enforceable environmental conditions, pushing for guarantees that Mercosur countries will comply with international climate agreements.

What’s next?

As the deal moves toward ratification, negotiators face an uphill battle to address France’s concerns. To appease critics, the EU may need to enhance monitoring mechanisms or include stricter environmental compliance measures. Failure to do so risks alienating a major EU power and delaying the deal indefinitely.

---

To receive more stories like this right in your inbox every week, subscribe below:

Subscribe